Quick Verdict: Garmin S44 v Garmin S50 GPS Golf Watch
Both the Garmin Approach S44 and S50 are outstanding mid-range GPS golf watches that share an impressive core, but they serve meaningfully different golfers.
The S44 at £249.99 is the focused golf-first choice: brilliant screen, full GPS course data, excellent battery life and all the key on-course features you need. The S50 at £329 goes further, adding comprehensive health and fitness tracking, Garmin Pay, music storage and PlaysLike Distance as standard – making it a serious all-day companion, not just a golf watch.
Both watches are covered by our 60-day no-quibble returns policy, so you can buy with complete confidence. Our PGA professional Mark Crossfield has reviewed both in his latest video, and his insight is woven throughout this guide to help you make the right choice.
Free Expert Tool
Garmin Approach S44 or S50?
Answer 5 quick questions and we will tell you which GPS golf watch is right for you.
Garmin S44 v Garmin S50: At a Glance
Feature
Approach S44 – £249.99
Approach S50 – £329
Display
1.2″ AMOLED 390x390px
1.2″ AMOLED 390x390px
Preloaded Courses
43,000+
43,000+
Battery (Smartwatch)
10 days
10 days
Battery (GPS Mode)
15 hours
15 hours
Weight
42g
29g
Strap Material
Silicone
ComfortFit Nylon
PlaysLike Distance
Membership required
Included as standard
Wrist Heart Rate
No
Yes
Garmin Pay
No
Yes
Music Storage
No
Yes (Spotify, Deezer, Amazon)
Sleep & Stress Tracking
Basic activity only
Full sleep, HRV, stress
Garmin Coach Plans
No
Yes
Water Rating
5 ATM
5 ATM
Gorilla Glass
Corning Gorilla Glass 3
Corning Gorilla Glass 3
Price
£249.99
£329
Both models feature: 43,000+ preloaded courses, AMOLED display, AutoShot tracking, Green View with pin positioning, smart notifications, CT10 club tracker compatibility, and 5 ATM water resistance.
Garmin Approach S44 v Garmin S50: The Mid-Range GPS Watch Battle of 2026
Garmin’s Approach range has long been the benchmark for serious GPS golf watches, and the new S44 and S50 represent a genuine step forward for mid-range technology. Replacing the well-regarded Approach S42, both watches arrive with stunning AMOLED screens, ultra-slim profiles, and battery life that puts even premium smartwatch rivals to shame. But which one is right for you?
The choice between the S44 and S50 is a genuinely interesting one – and it is not simply a matter of “spend more, get more.” Both watches deliver an exceptional on-course GPS experience. The question is really whether you want a dedicated golf watch or a full-time life companion that also happens to be exceptional on the fairway. This guide breaks down every feature, every difference, and every reason to choose one over the other.
Our PGA professional, Mark Crossfield, has tested both watches on the course, and his real-world video review provides the kind of hands-on insight that spec sheets simply cannot. We have also pulled every detail from the official product data, so whether you are drawn to the Garmin Approach S44 or the feature-rich Garmin Approach S50, you will leave with complete buying confidence. Both watches are available with our free UK standard delivery for life and 60-day no-quibble returns.
What Does Mark Crossfield Think?
Mark Crossfield’s First Impression: “The screen on both of these is so clear and Poppy outside – we’re just out on a golf course in daylight, and that is so impressive on both of them.”
Mark’s reaction to the displays perfectly captures what sets both watches apart from the competition. The AMOLED screens have to be seen in real daylight to be fully appreciated – and they are genuinely outstanding for outdoor use.
Mark explains in his latest video review that the form factor is one of the biggest talking points for both watches. “The standout features are not only the form factor for both of these watches – they are so interactable, really touch-friendly, easy to move around, and just so light and small. They actually do not look like a golf watch – they look more like a competitor for a life, good-looking watch you would be able to wear off the course.”
Mark on Battery Life: “Think about that – 15 hours GPS or 10 days if you do not. I mean, once or twice a week charging. I charge my Apple Watch every night – that is impressive.”
For anyone who has experienced the frustration of a dead watch mid-round, this comparison to everyday smartwatch charging habits puts the Garmin battery performance in sharp perspective.
When it comes to the key difference between the two, Mark is clear: “The golf features are really similar on both watches. The standout is on the S50 if you want that kind of day tracking ability – your life, your off-course kind of use of a watch. Where the S44 is more focused on the course only.”
Garmin Approach S44 GPS Golf Watch – Full Review
Design and Build Quality
The S44 makes an immediate impression with its sleek anodised aluminium bezel and vibrant 1.2-inch AMOLED touchscreen. At 42g it is remarkably light on the wrist, though as Mark notes, the S50’s nylon strap does give it a fractional weight advantage. The silicone strap on the S44 is comfortable for all-day wear, and the quick-release system makes swapping straps simple. Corning Gorilla Glass 3 protection means you genuinely do not need to coddle this watch – it is built for life on the course across all conditions.
The 390 x 390-pixel display delivers crisp, vibrant visuals that truly have to be seen to be believed in direct sunlight. The optional always-on mode is a practical touch for golfers who prefer at-a-glance yardages without needing to flick their wrist or tap the screen. Water resistance to 5 ATM means rain, and the occasional splash is no concern whatsoever.
Loading widget...
Golf Features
43,000+ Preloaded Courses
Global coverage with Auto CourseView updates. Simply put on the watch and play – no course downloads required before your round.
Green View & PinPointer
Full green view with manual pin positioning for exact distance control. PinPointer helps line up your shot even when the flag is not visible.
Garmin AutoShot
Automatically tracks and records shot distances throughout your round, feeding into your stats via the Garmin Golf app.
Tournament Mode
Switch to tournament-legal mode for competition rounds, disabling any features that could breach the rules of golf.
Garmin Approach S44 – Key Specifications
Display: 1.2-inch AMOLED, 390 x 390 pixels, always-on option
Battery (Smartwatch): Up to 10 days
Battery (GPS Mode): Up to 15 hours
GPS: Built-in GPS, GLONASS and Galileo
Weight: 42g
Strap: Silicone with quick-release bands
Lens: Corning Gorilla Glass 3
Water Resistance: 5 ATM
Courses: 43,000+ preloaded worldwide
Charger: Garmin proprietary plug
Price: £249.99
Strengths
Exceptional value at £249.99 for this level of golf tech
Outstanding AMOLED display – brilliant in all lighting conditions
10-day battery life means near-weekly charging at most
Full GPS course coverage with 43,000+ preloaded courses
AutoShot tracking builds a detailed round picture automatically
Tournament legal mode for competitive play
CT10 is compatible for full club-by-club tracking
Slim, stylish design that works on and off the course
Considerations
No heart rate monitor – fitness tracking is a basic step, and calorie data
PlaysLike Distance requires a Garmin Golf membership (additional cost)
No Garmin Pay – cannot make contactless payments
No music storage – will not replace your phone for audio
Silicone strap is slightly heavier than S50’s nylon alternative
Limited activity profiles compared to the S50
Who Should Buy the Garmin Approach S44?
Golfers who want a dedicated on-course GPS tool without paying for features they will not use
Players who already own a fitness tracker and do not need health monitoring in their watch
Anyone upgrading from an older GPS watch wants modern display technology
Golfers who play primarily social or competitive rounds and want tour-quality data
Budget-conscious buyers who want a premium feel at a mid-range price
Loading widget...
Garmin Approach S44 – Outstanding On-Course GPS
43,000+ courses, AMOLED display, 10-day battery. The golf-focused choice.
The S50 is genuinely one of the most impressive-feeling watches at this price point. At just 29g thanks to its ComfortFit nylon strap, Mark describes it as “ridiculously light” – and that is not hyperbole. Wearing the S50 you quickly forget it is on your wrist, which is the highest compliment you can pay a sports watch designed for extended daily use. The same 1.2-inch AMOLED touchscreen and Gorilla Glass 3 lens deliver identical display quality to the S44, and the physical dimensions (43 x 43 x 11.4mm) are virtually the same. This is a genuinely slim, stylish watch that works equally well at the 19th hole and the office.
Golf Features
On the course, the S50 matches the S44 feature for feature – and adds one genuinely valuable extra. PlaysLike Distance is included as standard, meaning every yardage is automatically adjusted for the slope and elevation change to the pin. This is the feature golfers sometimes call “slope” on their rangefinders, and having it built into your GPS watch yardages without needing a membership upgrade is a real advantage for anyone who plays hilly courses.
Loading widget...
PlaysLike Distance
Slope-adjusted yardages as standard. The watch calculates the effective playing distance, accounting for uphill and downhill elevation, to help you choose the right club.
Full Health Suite
Wrist-based heart rate, HRV status, sleep monitoring, stress tracking, Body Battery energy monitoring, Pulse Ox sensor and VO2 Max estimation.
Garmin Pay
Pay contactlessly from your wrist in the pro shop, cafe or clubhouse. No phone, no card – just tap and go.
Music Storage
Store and stream from Spotify, Deezer and Amazon Music directly from your watch – leaving your phone in the bag during practice rounds.
Garmin Approach S50 – Key Specifications
Display: 1.2-inch AMOLED, 390 x 390 pixels
Physical Size: 43 x 43 x 11.4mm
Battery (Smartwatch): Up to 10 days
Battery (GPS Mode): Up to 15 hours
Weight: 29g
Strap: ComfortFit Nylon (breathable)
Lens: Corning Gorilla Glass 3
Water Resistance: 5 ATM
Courses: 43,000+ preloaded worldwide
Heart Rate: Wrist-based continuous monitoring
Payment: Garmin Pay contactless
Music: Spotify, Deezer, Amazon Music
Price: £329
Loading widget...
Strengths
PlaysLike Distance included – slope-adjusted yardages without extra membership
Lightest in class at 29g – genuinely barely noticeable on the wrist
Full health monitoring – heart rate, HRV, sleep, stress, Pulse Ox, VO2 Max
Garmin Pay for contactless payments from your wrist
Music storage for Spotify, Deezer and Amazon Music
Garmin Coach training plans for fitness improvement
LiveTrack shares location with family for safety
Genuinely wear-all-day design – beautiful enough to replace a dress watch
Considerations
£79 more than the S44 – a meaningful price step
Extra features require engagement – you need to use the health data to get full value
Nylon strap – personal preference; some golfers prefer silicone
Garmin Golf membership still adds value for enhanced course mapping
Who Should Buy the Garmin Approach S50?
Golfers who want one watch to cover both on-course GPS and everyday health and fitness tracking
Players who want slope-adjusted yardages without relying on a separate rangefinder or membership
Anyone who regularly plays hilly courses where elevation significantly affects club selection
Golfers who walk to courses or cycle and want a genuine fitness companion
Those wanting the lightest possible watch with premium capabilities
Golfers who want contactless payment from their wrist in the clubhouse
Garmin Approach S50 – Your On and Off-Course Companion
PlaysLike Distance, Garmin Pay, full health suite and music at 29g.
If you play 40 rounds per year, the S44 works out at around £6.25 per round over two years. The S50 costs approximately £8.23 per round over the same period – a difference of just under £2 per round. For everything the S50 adds (slope, health monitoring, music, Garmin Pay), that is exceptional value for golfers who will genuinely use those features every day.
Performance Ratings – Garmin S44 v Garmin S50
Category
S44
S50
Display Quality
★★★★★
★★★★★
GPS Accuracy
★★★★★
★★★★★
Battery Life
★★★★★
★★★★★
Comfort and Wearability
★★★★★
★★★★★
Golf Feature Depth
★★★★★
★★★★★
Health and Fitness Tracking
★★★★★
★★★★★
Smart Features (Pay, Music)
★★★★★
★★★★★
Value for Money
★★★★★
★★★★★
Style and Aesthetics
★★★★★
★★★★★
Key Technologies Explained
AMOLED Display
Active Matrix Organic LED technology delivers vibrant, high-contrast visuals that remain crisp and readable in direct sunlight – a genuine weakness of older LCD golf watches.
The 390×390 pixel resolution on both the S44 and S50 is significantly sharper than most competing GPS watches at this price point.
Corning Gorilla Glass 3
The same scratch-resistant glass is found in many premium smartphones. As Mark highlights in his review, this gives both watches a durability that means you can wear them in the elements without anxiety – significantly more resilient than standard mineral glass.
PlaysLike Distance (S50)
Rather than showing the straight-line distance to the flag, PlaysLike Distance calculates the effective playing distance by factoring in the elevation change to the target.
A 150-yard uphill shot might display as 162 yards, helping you choose a full club more. This is the “slope” function golfers know from laser rangefinders like the Bushnell V7.
Garmin AutoShot
The accelerometers in both watches detect the motion of a golf swing and automatically record the GPS coordinates of each shot. After your round, the Garmin Golf app maps every shot, giving you a full distance breakdown by club and an aerial view of each hole you played.
HRV Status (S50)
Heart Rate Variability monitoring measures tiny fluctuations in the time between heartbeats during sleep.
This data is used to assess recovery, readiness to train, and long-term cardiovascular health – information that serious golfers and fitness enthusiasts can use to optimise their training and recovery schedule.
Body Battery (S50)
Garmin’s proprietary energy monitoring system combines HRV, stress, sleep, and activity data to give you a 0-100 score showing how much energy you have in reserve.
Knowing whether you are at 80% or 30% Body Battery before a round can help you manage your effort on the back nine.
Which Watch Should You Buy? The Definitive Buying Guide
Both the S44 and S50 are excellent watches. The decision really comes down to one core question: Are you buying a golf tool or a life companion? Here is how to think about it clearly.
Loading widget...
Mark Crossfield’s Buying Framework: “The S50 has a wide range of activities – meditation, swimming, strength and sleep tracking, heart rate access, Garmin Coach training plans, Garmin Pay. This is a real companion on and off the golf course. Where the S44 is more focused on the course only, and that is not to say the S44 does not offer some basic tracking of life options as well. The S44 gives you a toe-dip into that world, and the S50 is the one you would commit to if you are using that watch on and off.”
This framing from Mark is the clearest buying guide you will find. If you genuinely want an all-day companion that replaces your fitness band and your golf watch, the S50 is the obvious choice. If the course is your priority and life tracking is a nice-to-have rather than essential, the S44 delivers everything you need at a lower price.
Decision Tree: Garmin S44 v Garmin S50?
START HERE: What Matters Most to You?
Priority 1: Do you want slope-adjusted distances without paying for a membership?
PlaysLike Distance automatically adjusts yardages for uphill and downhill shots.
YES → Choose the Garmin Approach S50 (£329)
NO → Continue to Priority 2
Priority 2: Do you want full health and fitness tracking (heart rate, sleep, HRV)?
The S50 monitors your health around the clock. The S44 covers steps and basic activity only.
YES → Choose the Garmin Approach S50 (£329)
NO → Continue to Priority 3
Priority 3: Do you want to pay in the clubhouse from your wrist, or listen to music without your phone?
Garmin Pay and music storage are S50 exclusives.
YES → Choose the Garmin Approach S50 (£329)
NO → Continue to Priority 4
Priority 4: Is your budget closer to £250 and you primarily want a brilliant on-course GPS tool?
If all you need is outstanding course data, AMOLED clarity, and exceptional battery life, the S44 delivers all of it.
YES → Choose the Garmin Approach S44 (£249.99)
NO / UNSURE → Invest in the S50 – it is £79 more and covers every scenario
Which Watch for Which Golfer?
The Dedicated Golfer
Profile: Plays 2-3 times a week, competitive or social. Golf is the priority. Already has a fitness tracker or does not want one.
Recommendation:Garmin Approach S44 (£249.99)
Why: Everything needed on the course – brilliant GPS, AMOLED display, AutoShot, 43,000+ courses, 15-hour GPS battery. No wasted spend on features they will not use.
Profile: Golfs regularly but also runs, cycles, swims or goes to the gym. Wants one watch that works everywhere.
Recommendation:Garmin Approach S50 (£329)
Why: The S50 genuinely replaces a fitness band, a GPS watch and a sleep tracker in one 29g package. Heart rate, sleep, HRV, VO2 Max, Garmin Coach – it handles everything from the yoga mat to the fairway.
Consider pairing with:Golf Accessories from The Golf Shop Online to complete the setup.
The Tech-Forward Golfer
Profile: Wants the absolute best and most connected experience. Values slope data, music on the course, and contactless payment at the 19th hole.
Recommendation:Garmin Approach S50 (£329)
Why: PlaysLike Distance, Garmin Pay, music from Spotify and Deezer, LiveTrack and morning reports. The S50 is the most capable mid-range GPS watch available and looks stylish doing it.
Consider pairing with: Approach CT10 club trackers for the most comprehensive stats tracking available.
Not Sure Which Watch Is Right For You? Our PGA professional team, led by Mark Crossfield, is here to help you make the right call. Call us free on 0800 3681097 or email sales@thegolfshoponline.co.uk
Frequently Asked Questions – Garmin S44 v Garmin S50
What is the main difference between the Garmin Approach S44 and S50?
On the course, the two watches are nearly identical. Both feature the same stunning AMOLED display, the same 43,000+ preloaded courses, the same AutoShot tracking, the same Green View with manual pin positioning, and the same 10-day/15-hour battery life.
The differences emerge off the course and in a few key golf features. The S50 includes PlaysLike Distance (slope-adjusted yardages) as standard, while the S44 needs a Garmin Golf membership to access this. The S50 also adds full health monitoring (heart rate, sleep, HRV, stress, Pulse Ox, VO2 Max), Garmin Pay, music storage, Garmin Coach training plans and weighs just 29g compared to the S44’s 42g. If you want a golf watch, the S44 is superb. If you want a complete life watch that also excels on the course, choose the S50.
Does the Garmin Approach S44 or S50 include slope (PlaysLike Distance)?
The S50 includes PlaysLike Distance as standard; the S44 requires a Garmin Golf membership to unlock it.
PlaysLike Distance is Garmin’s equivalent of the slope function you may know from a laser rangefinder. It adjusts the displayed yardage to account for uphill or downhill elevation changes, so a 145-yard shot that plays uphill might display as 157 yards. For golfers who regularly play courses with significant elevation changes, this is a genuinely useful feature. On the S44, you can access it by subscribing to Garmin Golf’s premium membership. On the S50, it is built in with no additional subscription required.
How long does the battery last on the Garmin S44 and S50?
Both watches offer identical battery performance: up to 10 days in smartwatch mode and up to 15 hours with GPS active.
As Mark Crossfield notes in his video, this is genuinely remarkable for watches this slim. Even if you play twice a week with GPS on for four hours each round, you are looking at charging roughly once a week. Compare that to the nightly charging required by Apple Watch or many Android smartwatches, and the Garmin battery advantage is substantial. The 15-hour GPS mode is more than sufficient, even for the longest of rounds, combined with a practice session beforehand.
Are the Garmin Approach S44 and S50 suitable for everyday wear?
Yes, and this is one of the most impressive aspects of both watches – they look nothing like a traditional golf watch.
Mark specifically comments that both watches are slim enough and stylish enough to wear off the course without anyone identifying them as a specialist golf device. The S50 in particular, with its ultra-light 29g nylon strap, is designed as a genuine all-day companion. It handles swimming at 5 ATM water resistance, multiple activity profiles including yoga and meditation, and its smart styling suits casual and business environments equally well. The S44 is also entirely appropriate for daily wear – it simply does less health monitoring while you are wearing it.
Can I use these watches with a rangefinder or club tracking system?
Both the S44 and S50 are compatible with Garmin’s Approach CT10 and CT1 club tracking tags and work alongside rangefinders as part of the Garmin ecosystem.
The Approach CT10 tags attach to the grip of each club in your bag. When paired with either watch, they automatically record which club you used for each AutoShot, building a highly detailed picture of your distances club-by-club over time. This data feeds into the Garmin Golf app alongside your GPS round data. The watches also integrate with laser rangefinders – both work independently and complement each other rather than competing. Many golfers use their watch for hole overview and yardages while using a rangefinder like the Bushnell V7 for pin-precise distance.
What is the Garmin Golf membership, and do I need it?
The Garmin Golf membership is an optional subscription that unlocks enhanced features on both watches, but neither watch requires it to function excellently.
Both watches come fully operational out of the box with 43,000+ preloaded courses and all core GPS features. The membership adds enhanced CourseView mapping (the ability to scroll up and down the hole to plot your route), green contour maps, and PlaysLike Distance on the S44 (already included on the S50). For casual and club golfers, the free features are comprehensive. For golfers who want the deepest possible course intelligence, membership adds meaningful value.
Is the Garmin Approach S50 worth the extra £79 over the S44?
For golfers who want a single watch for both golf and everyday health and fitness tracking – yes, absolutely.
The S50’s £79 premium delivers: built-in slope (PlaysLike Distance) saving you a membership cost, full health monitoring replacing a separate fitness tracker, Garmin Pay, music storage, a meaningfully lighter 29g weight, and one of the most comprehensive all-round GPS watches at this price anywhere. If you already own a fitness tracker and purely want an on-course GPS tool, the S44 at £249.99 is genuinely outstanding and there is no need to spend more. The decision is simpler than it looks – it comes down to whether you want one watch to do everything.
Why Purchase Your Garmin Watch from The Golf Shop Online?
Award-Winning Service Since 2002
Average Rating: 4.9 out of 5.0
29,000+ Total Reviews
8,000+ on Reviews.co.uk • 6,000+ on Trustpilot • 15,000+ on Google
Led by PGA professional Mark Crossfield, with over 330 million YouTube views
Loading widget...
60-Day No-Quibble Returns
Not quite right? Return your Garmin watch unused within 60 days for a full refund, no questions asked. Complete buying confidence guaranteed.
Official Authorised Garmin Retailer
We are an authorised Garmin Golf retailer. Every watch comes with the full manufacturer’s 2-year warranty and is genuine UK-spec.
Expert PGA Guidance
Not sure which model suits your game? Our team of 4 PGA professionals, led by Mark Crossfield, can help. Call free on 0800 3681097.
Free UK Standard Delivery
Every Garmin order includes free UK standard delivery.
Lowest Price Promise
We are committed to competitive pricing on every product we sell. Found it cheaper elsewhere? Get in touch – we want to earn your business.
Real Golfers, Real Reviews
29,000+ verified reviews from real customers across three independent platforms. Our 4.9-star average speaks for itself.
Final Verdict – Garmin S44 v Garmin S50
Garmin Approach S44 – Our Verdict
The S44 is a genuinely brilliant GPS golf watch at a price that makes it accessible to a wide range of golfers. The AMOLED display is one of the best in class at any price. The battery life is exceptional. The course database is comprehensive. If you want a purpose-built golf GPS watch with modern screen technology and you are not looking to replace a fitness tracker, the S44 at £249.99 is exceptional value and easy to recommend.
Garmin Approach S50 – Our Verdict
The S50 is the watch we would choose if we were buying just one watch for everything. At 29g, it is barely there on the wrist. It delivers everything the S44 does on the course, and then a great deal more besides – slope, health, music, Garmin Pay, sleep tracking. The £79 premium over the S44 buys you a genuinely comprehensive life companion. For golfers ready to commit to a watch that works as hard off the course as on it, the S50 is outstanding.
Mark Crossfield’s Bottom Line: “For me, the standout features are not only the form factor for both of these watches – they are so interactable, really touch-friendly, easy to move around, and just so light and small. They actually do not look like a golf watch. Loving these.”
High praise from a PGA professional with over 330 million YouTube views who has tested virtually every GPS watch on the market. Both watches have earned that endorsement – the only question is which one fits your life.
All equipment sold by The Golf Shop Online conforms fully to the specifications set out by The R&A, ensuring every watch you purchase is tournament-legal for competition play when used in the appropriate mode.
Golf Waterproofs – Stay dry and comfortable in all conditions with our waterproof range
Golf Shoes – The right footwear completes every golfer’s on-course setup
Disclaimer: Prices, specifications, and availability are accurate as of publication but may change. All featured Garmin products are genuine, sourced from an authorised retailer. Product performance may vary based on individual use and conditions. Our 60-day no-quibble returns policy applies to unused items returned within 60 days of purchase. For the most current pricing, availability, and product specifications, please visit our website or contact our team on 0800 3681097. The Golf Shop Online has been serving golfers since 2002 with award-winning customer service backed by 29,000+ verified reviews across Reviews.co.uk, Trustpilot, and Google.
The Golf Shop Online takes immense pride in its extensive selection of high-quality branded golf equipment, all available at exceptionally affordable prices. In addition to this, the shop offers valuable insights and guidance from PGA professional golfers.
Their team is led by the esteemed resident professional, James Langmead. James previously earned the prestigious title of Callaway club fitter of the year and was a vital member of the Callaway CFS testing panel.
At The Golf Shop Online, customers can expect not only top-notch products but also expert advice from seasoned professionals in the golfing industry. Whether you're a seasoned golfer or a beginner looking to refine your game, their knowledge and expertise are readily available to assist you in making informed choices for your golfing needs.
Titleist SM11 Wedges – The Ultimate Guide for 2026
![X [Twitter]](https://www.thegolfshoponline.co.uk/assets/themes/gso2022/images/footer/icon-x.png){kind=icon}
Garmin S44 v Garmin S50: The Ultimate GPS Golf Watch Comparison Guide
Quick Verdict: Garmin S44 v Garmin S50 GPS Golf Watch
Both the Garmin Approach S44 and S50 are outstanding mid-range GPS golf watches that share an impressive core, but they serve meaningfully different golfers.
The S44 at £249.99 is the focused golf-first choice: brilliant screen, full GPS course data, excellent battery life and all the key on-course features you need. The S50 at £329 goes further, adding comprehensive health and fitness tracking, Garmin Pay, music storage and PlaysLike Distance as standard – making it a serious all-day companion, not just a golf watch.
Both watches are covered by our 60-day no-quibble returns policy, so you can buy with complete confidence. Our PGA professional Mark Crossfield has reviewed both in his latest video, and his insight is woven throughout this guide to help you make the right choice.
Garmin Approach S44 or S50?
Answer 5 quick questions and we will tell you which GPS golf watch is right for you.
Garmin S44 v Garmin S50: At a Glance
Both models feature: 43,000+ preloaded courses, AMOLED display, AutoShot tracking, Green View with pin positioning, smart notifications, CT10 club tracker compatibility, and 5 ATM water resistance.
Quick Navigation
→ Mark Crossfield’s Take
→ Garmin Approach S44 Review
→ Garmin Approach S50 Review
→ Full Feature Comparison
→ Performance Ratings
→ Which Watch Should You Buy?
→ Decision Tree
→ Player Profiles
→ FAQs
→ Final Verdict
Garmin Approach S44 v Garmin S50: The Mid-Range GPS Watch Battle of 2026
Garmin’s Approach range has long been the benchmark for serious GPS golf watches, and the new S44 and S50 represent a genuine step forward for mid-range technology. Replacing the well-regarded Approach S42, both watches arrive with stunning AMOLED screens, ultra-slim profiles, and battery life that puts even premium smartwatch rivals to shame. But which one is right for you?
The choice between the S44 and S50 is a genuinely interesting one – and it is not simply a matter of “spend more, get more.” Both watches deliver an exceptional on-course GPS experience. The question is really whether you want a dedicated golf watch or a full-time life companion that also happens to be exceptional on the fairway. This guide breaks down every feature, every difference, and every reason to choose one over the other.
Our PGA professional, Mark Crossfield, has tested both watches on the course, and his real-world video review provides the kind of hands-on insight that spec sheets simply cannot. We have also pulled every detail from the official product data, so whether you are drawn to the Garmin Approach S44 or the feature-rich Garmin Approach S50, you will leave with complete buying confidence. Both watches are available with our free UK standard delivery for life and 60-day no-quibble returns.
What Does Mark Crossfield Think?
Mark Crossfield’s First Impression: “The screen on both of these is so clear and Poppy outside – we’re just out on a golf course in daylight, and that is so impressive on both of them.”
Mark’s reaction to the displays perfectly captures what sets both watches apart from the competition. The AMOLED screens have to be seen in real daylight to be fully appreciated – and they are genuinely outstanding for outdoor use.
Mark explains in his latest video review that the form factor is one of the biggest talking points for both watches. “The standout features are not only the form factor for both of these watches – they are so interactable, really touch-friendly, easy to move around, and just so light and small. They actually do not look like a golf watch – they look more like a competitor for a life, good-looking watch you would be able to wear off the course.”
Mark on Battery Life: “Think about that – 15 hours GPS or 10 days if you do not. I mean, once or twice a week charging. I charge my Apple Watch every night – that is impressive.”
For anyone who has experienced the frustration of a dead watch mid-round, this comparison to everyday smartwatch charging habits puts the Garmin battery performance in sharp perspective.
When it comes to the key difference between the two, Mark is clear: “The golf features are really similar on both watches. The standout is on the S50 if you want that kind of day tracking ability – your life, your off-course kind of use of a watch. Where the S44 is more focused on the course only.”
Garmin Approach S44 GPS Golf Watch – Full Review
Design and Build Quality
The S44 makes an immediate impression with its sleek anodised aluminium bezel and vibrant 1.2-inch AMOLED touchscreen. At 42g it is remarkably light on the wrist, though as Mark notes, the S50’s nylon strap does give it a fractional weight advantage. The silicone strap on the S44 is comfortable for all-day wear, and the quick-release system makes swapping straps simple. Corning Gorilla Glass 3 protection means you genuinely do not need to coddle this watch – it is built for life on the course across all conditions.
The 390 x 390-pixel display delivers crisp, vibrant visuals that truly have to be seen to be believed in direct sunlight. The optional always-on mode is a practical touch for golfers who prefer at-a-glance yardages without needing to flick their wrist or tap the screen. Water resistance to 5 ATM means rain, and the occasional splash is no concern whatsoever.
Golf Features
43,000+ Preloaded Courses
Global coverage with Auto CourseView updates. Simply put on the watch and play – no course downloads required before your round.
Green View & PinPointer
Full green view with manual pin positioning for exact distance control. PinPointer helps line up your shot even when the flag is not visible.
Garmin AutoShot
Automatically tracks and records shot distances throughout your round, feeding into your stats via the Garmin Golf app.
Tournament Mode
Switch to tournament-legal mode for competition rounds, disabling any features that could breach the rules of golf.
Garmin Approach S44 – Key Specifications
Strengths
Considerations
Who Should Buy the Garmin Approach S44?
Garmin Approach S44 – Outstanding On-Course GPS
43,000+ courses, AMOLED display, 10-day battery. The golf-focused choice.
£249.99 – Free UK Delivery
Shop Garmin Approach S44 →
Garmin Approach S50 GPS Golf Watch – Full Review
Design and Build Quality
The S50 is genuinely one of the most impressive-feeling watches at this price point. At just 29g thanks to its ComfortFit nylon strap, Mark describes it as “ridiculously light” – and that is not hyperbole. Wearing the S50 you quickly forget it is on your wrist, which is the highest compliment you can pay a sports watch designed for extended daily use. The same 1.2-inch AMOLED touchscreen and Gorilla Glass 3 lens deliver identical display quality to the S44, and the physical dimensions (43 x 43 x 11.4mm) are virtually the same. This is a genuinely slim, stylish watch that works equally well at the 19th hole and the office.
Golf Features
On the course, the S50 matches the S44 feature for feature – and adds one genuinely valuable extra. PlaysLike Distance is included as standard, meaning every yardage is automatically adjusted for the slope and elevation change to the pin. This is the feature golfers sometimes call “slope” on their rangefinders, and having it built into your GPS watch yardages without needing a membership upgrade is a real advantage for anyone who plays hilly courses.
PlaysLike Distance
Slope-adjusted yardages as standard. The watch calculates the effective playing distance, accounting for uphill and downhill elevation, to help you choose the right club.
Full Health Suite
Wrist-based heart rate, HRV status, sleep monitoring, stress tracking, Body Battery energy monitoring, Pulse Ox sensor and VO2 Max estimation.
Garmin Pay
Pay contactlessly from your wrist in the pro shop, cafe or clubhouse. No phone, no card – just tap and go.
Music Storage
Store and stream from Spotify, Deezer and Amazon Music directly from your watch – leaving your phone in the bag during practice rounds.
Garmin Approach S50 – Key Specifications
Strengths
Considerations
Who Should Buy the Garmin Approach S50?
Garmin Approach S50 – Your On and Off-Course Companion
PlaysLike Distance, Garmin Pay, full health suite and music at 29g.
£329 – Free UK Delivery
Shop Garmin Approach S50 →
Full Feature-by-Feature Comparison
On-Course Golf Features – Garmin S44 v Garmin S50
Health, Fitness and Smart Features
Value Insight: Cost Per Round Perspective
If you play 40 rounds per year, the S44 works out at around £6.25 per round over two years. The S50 costs approximately £8.23 per round over the same period – a difference of just under £2 per round. For everything the S50 adds (slope, health monitoring, music, Garmin Pay), that is exceptional value for golfers who will genuinely use those features every day.
Performance Ratings – Garmin S44 v Garmin S50
Key Technologies Explained
AMOLED Display
Active Matrix Organic LED technology delivers vibrant, high-contrast visuals that remain crisp and readable in direct sunlight – a genuine weakness of older LCD golf watches.
The 390×390 pixel resolution on both the S44 and S50 is significantly sharper than most competing GPS watches at this price point.
Corning Gorilla Glass 3
The same scratch-resistant glass is found in many premium smartphones. As Mark highlights in his review, this gives both watches a durability that means you can wear them in the elements without anxiety – significantly more resilient than standard mineral glass.
PlaysLike Distance (S50)
Rather than showing the straight-line distance to the flag, PlaysLike Distance calculates the effective playing distance by factoring in the elevation change to the target.
A 150-yard uphill shot might display as 162 yards, helping you choose a full club more. This is the “slope” function golfers know from laser rangefinders like the Bushnell V7.
Garmin AutoShot
The accelerometers in both watches detect the motion of a golf swing and automatically record the GPS coordinates of each shot. After your round, the Garmin Golf app maps every shot, giving you a full distance breakdown by club and an aerial view of each hole you played.
HRV Status (S50)
Heart Rate Variability monitoring measures tiny fluctuations in the time between heartbeats during sleep.
This data is used to assess recovery, readiness to train, and long-term cardiovascular health – information that serious golfers and fitness enthusiasts can use to optimise their training and recovery schedule.
Body Battery (S50)
Garmin’s proprietary energy monitoring system combines HRV, stress, sleep, and activity data to give you a 0-100 score showing how much energy you have in reserve.
Knowing whether you are at 80% or 30% Body Battery before a round can help you manage your effort on the back nine.
Which Watch Should You Buy? The Definitive Buying Guide
Both the S44 and S50 are excellent watches. The decision really comes down to one core question: Are you buying a golf tool or a life companion? Here is how to think about it clearly.
Mark Crossfield’s Buying Framework: “The S50 has a wide range of activities – meditation, swimming, strength and sleep tracking, heart rate access, Garmin Coach training plans, Garmin Pay. This is a real companion on and off the golf course. Where the S44 is more focused on the course only, and that is not to say the S44 does not offer some basic tracking of life options as well. The S44 gives you a toe-dip into that world, and the S50 is the one you would commit to if you are using that watch on and off.”
This framing from Mark is the clearest buying guide you will find. If you genuinely want an all-day companion that replaces your fitness band and your golf watch, the S50 is the obvious choice. If the course is your priority and life tracking is a nice-to-have rather than essential, the S44 delivers everything you need at a lower price.
Decision Tree: Garmin S44 v Garmin S50?
Priority 1: Do you want slope-adjusted distances without paying for a membership?
PlaysLike Distance automatically adjusts yardages for uphill and downhill shots.
Priority 2: Do you want full health and fitness tracking (heart rate, sleep, HRV)?
The S50 monitors your health around the clock. The S44 covers steps and basic activity only.
Priority 3: Do you want to pay in the clubhouse from your wrist, or listen to music without your phone?
Garmin Pay and music storage are S50 exclusives.
Priority 4: Is your budget closer to £250 and you primarily want a brilliant on-course GPS tool?
If all you need is outstanding course data, AMOLED clarity, and exceptional battery life, the S44 delivers all of it.
Which Watch for Which Golfer?
The Dedicated Golfer
Profile: Plays 2-3 times a week, competitive or social. Golf is the priority. Already has a fitness tracker or does not want one.
Recommendation: Garmin Approach S44 (£249.99)
Why: Everything needed on the course – brilliant GPS, AMOLED display, AutoShot, 43,000+ courses, 15-hour GPS battery. No wasted spend on features they will not use.
Consider pairing with: Bushnell V7 Rangefinder for the sharpest possible distances.
The Active All-Rounder
Profile: Golfs regularly but also runs, cycles, swims or goes to the gym. Wants one watch that works everywhere.
Recommendation: Garmin Approach S50 (£329)
Why: The S50 genuinely replaces a fitness band, a GPS watch and a sleep tracker in one 29g package. Heart rate, sleep, HRV, VO2 Max, Garmin Coach – it handles everything from the yoga mat to the fairway.
Consider pairing with: Golf Accessories from The Golf Shop Online to complete the setup.
The Tech-Forward Golfer
Profile: Wants the absolute best and most connected experience. Values slope data, music on the course, and contactless payment at the 19th hole.
Recommendation: Garmin Approach S50 (£329)
Why: PlaysLike Distance, Garmin Pay, music from Spotify and Deezer, LiveTrack and morning reports. The S50 is the most capable mid-range GPS watch available and looks stylish doing it.
Consider pairing with: Approach CT10 club trackers for the most comprehensive stats tracking available.
Not Sure Which Watch Is Right For You? Our PGA professional team, led by Mark Crossfield, is here to help you make the right call. Call us free on 0800 3681097 or email sales@thegolfshoponline.co.uk
Frequently Asked Questions – Garmin S44 v Garmin S50
What is the main difference between the Garmin Approach S44 and S50?
On the course, the two watches are nearly identical. Both feature the same stunning AMOLED display, the same 43,000+ preloaded courses, the same AutoShot tracking, the same Green View with manual pin positioning, and the same 10-day/15-hour battery life.
The differences emerge off the course and in a few key golf features. The S50 includes PlaysLike Distance (slope-adjusted yardages) as standard, while the S44 needs a Garmin Golf membership to access this. The S50 also adds full health monitoring (heart rate, sleep, HRV, stress, Pulse Ox, VO2 Max), Garmin Pay, music storage, Garmin Coach training plans and weighs just 29g compared to the S44’s 42g. If you want a golf watch, the S44 is superb. If you want a complete life watch that also excels on the course, choose the S50.
Does the Garmin Approach S44 or S50 include slope (PlaysLike Distance)?
The S50 includes PlaysLike Distance as standard; the S44 requires a Garmin Golf membership to unlock it.
PlaysLike Distance is Garmin’s equivalent of the slope function you may know from a laser rangefinder. It adjusts the displayed yardage to account for uphill or downhill elevation changes, so a 145-yard shot that plays uphill might display as 157 yards. For golfers who regularly play courses with significant elevation changes, this is a genuinely useful feature. On the S44, you can access it by subscribing to Garmin Golf’s premium membership. On the S50, it is built in with no additional subscription required.
How long does the battery last on the Garmin S44 and S50?
Both watches offer identical battery performance: up to 10 days in smartwatch mode and up to 15 hours with GPS active.
As Mark Crossfield notes in his video, this is genuinely remarkable for watches this slim. Even if you play twice a week with GPS on for four hours each round, you are looking at charging roughly once a week. Compare that to the nightly charging required by Apple Watch or many Android smartwatches, and the Garmin battery advantage is substantial. The 15-hour GPS mode is more than sufficient, even for the longest of rounds, combined with a practice session beforehand.
Are the Garmin Approach S44 and S50 suitable for everyday wear?
Yes, and this is one of the most impressive aspects of both watches – they look nothing like a traditional golf watch.
Mark specifically comments that both watches are slim enough and stylish enough to wear off the course without anyone identifying them as a specialist golf device. The S50 in particular, with its ultra-light 29g nylon strap, is designed as a genuine all-day companion. It handles swimming at 5 ATM water resistance, multiple activity profiles including yoga and meditation, and its smart styling suits casual and business environments equally well. The S44 is also entirely appropriate for daily wear – it simply does less health monitoring while you are wearing it.
Can I use these watches with a rangefinder or club tracking system?
Both the S44 and S50 are compatible with Garmin’s Approach CT10 and CT1 club tracking tags and work alongside rangefinders as part of the Garmin ecosystem.
The Approach CT10 tags attach to the grip of each club in your bag. When paired with either watch, they automatically record which club you used for each AutoShot, building a highly detailed picture of your distances club-by-club over time. This data feeds into the Garmin Golf app alongside your GPS round data. The watches also integrate with laser rangefinders – both work independently and complement each other rather than competing. Many golfers use their watch for hole overview and yardages while using a rangefinder like the Bushnell V7 for pin-precise distance.
What is the Garmin Golf membership, and do I need it?
The Garmin Golf membership is an optional subscription that unlocks enhanced features on both watches, but neither watch requires it to function excellently.
Both watches come fully operational out of the box with 43,000+ preloaded courses and all core GPS features. The membership adds enhanced CourseView mapping (the ability to scroll up and down the hole to plot your route), green contour maps, and PlaysLike Distance on the S44 (already included on the S50). For casual and club golfers, the free features are comprehensive. For golfers who want the deepest possible course intelligence, membership adds meaningful value.
Is the Garmin Approach S50 worth the extra £79 over the S44?
For golfers who want a single watch for both golf and everyday health and fitness tracking – yes, absolutely.
The S50’s £79 premium delivers: built-in slope (PlaysLike Distance) saving you a membership cost, full health monitoring replacing a separate fitness tracker, Garmin Pay, music storage, a meaningfully lighter 29g weight, and one of the most comprehensive all-round GPS watches at this price anywhere. If you already own a fitness tracker and purely want an on-course GPS tool, the S44 at £249.99 is genuinely outstanding and there is no need to spend more. The decision is simpler than it looks – it comes down to whether you want one watch to do everything.
Why Purchase Your Garmin Watch from The Golf Shop Online?
Award-Winning Service Since 2002
Average Rating: 4.9 out of 5.0
29,000+ Total Reviews
8,000+ on Reviews.co.uk • 6,000+ on Trustpilot • 15,000+ on Google
Led by PGA professional Mark Crossfield, with over 330 million YouTube views
60-Day No-Quibble Returns
Not quite right? Return your Garmin watch unused within 60 days for a full refund, no questions asked. Complete buying confidence guaranteed.
Official Authorised Garmin Retailer
We are an authorised Garmin Golf retailer. Every watch comes with the full manufacturer’s 2-year warranty and is genuine UK-spec.
Expert PGA Guidance
Not sure which model suits your game? Our team of 4 PGA professionals, led by Mark Crossfield, can help. Call free on 0800 3681097.
Free UK Standard Delivery
Every Garmin order includes free UK standard delivery.
Lowest Price Promise
We are committed to competitive pricing on every product we sell. Found it cheaper elsewhere? Get in touch – we want to earn your business.
Real Golfers, Real Reviews
29,000+ verified reviews from real customers across three independent platforms. Our 4.9-star average speaks for itself.
Final Verdict – Garmin S44 v Garmin S50
Garmin Approach S44 – Our Verdict
The S44 is a genuinely brilliant GPS golf watch at a price that makes it accessible to a wide range of golfers. The AMOLED display is one of the best in class at any price. The battery life is exceptional. The course database is comprehensive. If you want a purpose-built golf GPS watch with modern screen technology and you are not looking to replace a fitness tracker, the S44 at £249.99 is exceptional value and easy to recommend.
Garmin Approach S50 – Our Verdict
The S50 is the watch we would choose if we were buying just one watch for everything. At 29g, it is barely there on the wrist. It delivers everything the S44 does on the course, and then a great deal more besides – slope, health, music, Garmin Pay, sleep tracking. The £79 premium over the S44 buys you a genuinely comprehensive life companion. For golfers ready to commit to a watch that works as hard off the course as on it, the S50 is outstanding.
Mark Crossfield’s Bottom Line: “For me, the standout features are not only the form factor for both of these watches – they are so interactable, really touch-friendly, easy to move around, and just so light and small. They actually do not look like a golf watch. Loving these.”
High praise from a PGA professional with over 330 million YouTube views who has tested virtually every GPS watch on the market. Both watches have earned that endorsement – the only question is which one fits your life.
All equipment sold by The Golf Shop Online conforms fully to the specifications set out by The R&A, ensuring every watch you purchase is tournament-legal for competition play when used in the appropriate mode.
Shop Both Garmin GPS Golf Watches
Free UK Delivery • Authorised Garmin Retailer • 2-Year Warranty • 60-Day Returns
Garmin Approach S44 – £249.99 →
Garmin Approach S50 – £329 →
Complete Your Setup: Related Golf Equipment
Disclaimer: Prices, specifications, and availability are accurate as of publication but may change. All featured Garmin products are genuine, sourced from an authorised retailer. Product performance may vary based on individual use and conditions. Our 60-day no-quibble returns policy applies to unused items returned within 60 days of purchase. For the most current pricing, availability, and product specifications, please visit our website or contact our team on 0800 3681097. The Golf Shop Online has been serving golfers since 2002 with award-winning customer service backed by 29,000+ verified reviews across Reviews.co.uk, Trustpilot, and Google.
About James Langmead
The Golf Shop Online takes immense pride in its extensive selection of high-quality branded golf equipment, all available at exceptionally affordable prices. In addition to this, the shop offers valuable insights and guidance from PGA professional golfers. Their team is led by the esteemed resident professional, James Langmead. James previously earned the prestigious title of Callaway club fitter of the year and was a vital member of the Callaway CFS testing panel. At The Golf Shop Online, customers can expect not only top-notch products but also expert advice from seasoned professionals in the golfing industry. Whether you're a seasoned golfer or a beginner looking to refine your game, their knowledge and expertise are readily available to assist you in making informed choices for your golfing needs.Related Posts