- Ping S259 Vs Vokey SM11 – Which £179 Wedge Wins?Posted 30 seconds ago
- Best Zero Torque Putters 2026: Top 5 Ranked by PGA ProsPosted 1 day ago
- Best Golf Quarter Zip Sweaters 2026: Our Top 5 PicksPosted 1 day ago
- 5 Best 14-Way Golf Stand Bags, Ranked (2026)Posted 2 days ago
- 5 Best Golf Jackets Under £100: Ranked for AutumnPosted 2 days ago
- Best Men’s Golf Trousers 2026: Our Top 5 PicksPosted 2 days ago
- Garmin S72 Review: The Ultimate Golf Watch?Posted 3 days ago
- Srixon Soft Feel vs Callaway Super Soft – Which Ball Wins the Distance and Feel Battle?Posted 6 days ago
- Srixon ZXi RKT Driver: The Ultimate Guide to All 3 ModelsPosted 6 days ago
- Ping G440 Irons Review 2026: Is This Ping’s Best Game-Improvement Set Ever?Posted 6 days ago
Ping S259 Vs Vokey SM11 – Which £179 Wedge Wins?
Ping S259 vs Vokey SM11 Nickel: Which £179 Wedge Wins?
Ping S259 Vs Vokey SM11
Best for forgiveness Ping Golf S259 Midnight Golf Wedge Shop Now |
Best for tour feel Titleist Vokey SM11 Nickel Steel Wedge Shop Now |
|
|---|---|---|
| Our rating | ★★★★★ | ★★★★☆ |
| Price | £179 | £179 |
| Best for | Golfers wanting grind choice and a forgiving wide-sole option | Players who like a lower, controlled flight and classic Vokey feel |
| Finish | Anti-glare Midnight black | Nickel Steel, a softer mid-glare hue |
| Grind options | Six: S, T, W, E, H and B | Six: F, M, S, D, K and T |
| Face and grooves | Precision-milled wheel-cut grooves with friction-adding face blast | Spin-milled grooves with heat-treated face |
| Key technology | Milled groove sidewall angles tuned for lower lofts | Vokey Spin System with higher, more forward centre of gravity |
| Standard shaft and grip | PING Z-Z115 steel shaft, PING 360 Dyla-wedge Lite grip | Options on the product page, custom fitting available |
| Shop Now | Shop Now |
Tip: scroll the table sideways on mobile to see all columns.
Ping S259 vs Vokey SM11 Nickel: Choosing Your £179 Wedge
Your wedges do more for your scorecard than almost any other club in the bag. Most golfers hit them for a third or more of their shots, from the fairway, the rough, the sand and the fringe. Choosing between two very good options at the same price makes it harder, not easier.
That is exactly the dilemma with these two. The Ping S259 Midnight Golf Wedge comes from a brand famous for forgiveness and fitting, and it builds on the tour-winning heritage of the S159. The Titleist Vokey SM11 Nickel Steel Wedge comes from the wedge family Titleist describes as the most played on Tour. Both cost £179, so price will not help you decide.
This comparison is for golfers who already know they want a premium steel-shafted wedge and need help choosing. If you are still deciding which loft you need, our guide to the best golf wedges for spin is a good place to start. You can also browse the full golf clubs range for fairways, irons and putters. Otherwise, read on.
Best for forgiveness: Ping S259 Midnight Golf Wedge
An anti-glare Midnight wedge with six tour-inspired grinds, precision-milled grooves and a friction-adding face blast. It suits golfers of all abilities who want choice and consistency.
What makes the Ping S259 Midnight special
The Ping S259 builds on the S159, one of the most successful wedge families Ping has made, and refines it in all the right places. The Midnight version adds a sophisticated dark coating that cuts reflections and gives a compact, clean look at address.
Underneath the finish, the engineering is serious. Every wedge has precision-milled wheel-cut grooves and a friction-adding face blast, designed to deliver consistent launch and spin from all distances. For the lower lofts, from 46° to 52°, the groove sidewall angles are changed to maximise groove volume, which helps with control on full shots into the green.
Anti-glare Midnight finish
A dark coating reduces reflections and gives a visually compact look at address, so you can focus on the ball rather than the glare.
Precision-milled grooves
Wheel-cut grooves are tuned for the lower lofts to maximise groove volume and deliver full-shot control.
High-spin face blast
Surface texture adds friction to the face, which supports spin and consistent stopping power around the green.
Six refined grinds
S, T, W, E, H and B grinds are available, so you can match the sole to your attack angle and typical turf.
Grinds and lofts explained
The grind range is where the Ping S259 really stands out. The new H, or half-moon, grind suits golfers with a steeper angle of attack or those who play in softer conditions. The B grind is a low-bounce design for shallow attack angles and firmer turf. The T grind is the most versatile, engineered for medium-firm conditions and precise shot-making.
The W grind has a wider sole that delivers unmatched forgiveness for a specialist wedge, making it a smart choice for steeper swingers and golfers who use a lot of handle lean. The E grind carries on Ping’s 40-year bunker tradition, and the S grind fits the broadest range of techniques. Lofts run from 46° to 62° in 2° steps.
Who the Ping suits best
The S259 Midnight is for golfers who like options. If you are building a wedge set and want smooth gapping with your irons, the wide loft range and expanded grind choice make that simple.
It comes with the PING Z-Z115 Wedge steel shaft and the PING 360 Dyla-wedge Lite grip. If you already play Ping irons, the Ping range makes it easy to build a matching set. Our PGA professional team can help you choose the right grind and loft combination for your swing and your home course.
- Six grinds give you a wide choice of sole shape
- Anti-glare Midnight finish looks sharp and reduces distraction
- Precision-milled grooves and face blast support consistent spin
- Wide loft range from 46° to 62° makes gapping simple
- Dark finish may show wear with heavy use, as any coated finish can
- Choosing between six grinds takes some thought
- Not the classic shaping some traditional players prefer
Ready to try the Ping S259 Midnight?
Free UK standard delivery on orders over £30 and our 60-Day Returns Policy.
Best for tour feel: Titleist Vokey SM11 Nickel Steel Wedge
The latest Vokey wedge brings a new Vokey Spin System, a higher, more forward centre of gravity, and a heat-treated face. The Nickel Steel finish offers a softer, mid-glare look than traditional chrome.
What makes the Vokey SM11 special
Titleist calls the SM11 the next chapter in the most played wedge family on Tour, and the headline change is the new Vokey Spin System. It is an engineering process designed to make greenside control more predictable, so the spin you get on a pitch from 40 yards is closer to the spin you expect, shot after shot.
The second big idea is centre of gravity. By moving the CG higher and more forward, the SM11 promotes a lower, more controlled trajectory with improved feel and stability through impact.
Vokey Spin System
A new engineering process that creates more predictable greenside control and more consistent spin levels.
Forward CG placement
The centre of gravity sits higher and further forward for a lower, more penetrating flight and better stability.
Spin-milled grooves
Every groove is inspected to ensure maximum spin and stopping power in all conditions.
Heat-treated face
A proprietary heat treatment on the impact area is designed to double groove life without sacrificing feel.
Grinds and finish explained
The Vokey grind range covers every technique. The F grind is the all-purpose option, the most played sand wedge on Tour, and best for full swings and square-faced shots. The M grind suits players who like to open and close the face. The S grind is narrow and versatile, and the T grind is the low-bounce shotmaker’s choice for tight lies and firm turf.
For softer, grainier conditions, the D grind adds high bounce for steeper swings, and the K grind is the most forgiving, with a wide, full sole and extra camber. The Nickel Steel finish is a slightly softer hue than traditional chrome, reducing glare while keeping the crisp lines Vokey is known for. It is also available in tour chrome and jet black.
Who the Vokey suits best
The SM11 Nickel Steel is for golfers who prize feel and flight control, and who are happy to think about the grind that suits their swing. It is a natural fit for the better player, but the K and D grinds make it friendlier than its reputation suggests. If you play Titleist irons, the Titleist range makes matching your set easy.
Full custom fit options are available, and our team can talk you through lofts and grinds. To see how the SM11 compares with another premium rival, check out our Vokey SM11 vs TaylorMade Milled Grind 5 comparison.
- Vokey Spin System supports predictable greenside spin
- Forward CG promotes a lower, more controlled flight
- Heat-treated face is designed for longer groove life
- Six grinds, including forgiving K and high-bounce D options
- Choosing the right grind takes some thought
- The classic shaping is less forgiving than a wide-sole design
- Fewer shaft and grip details are listed, so check the options on the product page
Ready to try the Titleist Vokey SM11 Nickel Steel?
Custom fitting is available, with free UK standard delivery over £30 and our 60-Day Returns Policy.
Head-to-head
On paper, these wedges are close. Both are steel wedges with milled grooves, a premium finish and a wide range of grinds. The difference is what each is trying to do for your short game, so here is how they compare on what matters on the course.
Feel and flight
The Vokey is the more feel-led wedge. Its higher and more forward centre of gravity is designed to produce a lower, more controlled flight with improved feel through impact, which many better players love. The Ping delivers a consistent launch and spin profile, and its grooves and face blast give a reassuringly grabby feel on short shots.
Grind choice and forgiveness
Both offer six grinds, so choice is a draw on numbers. The Ping edges it for forgiveness, with the W grind and its wide sole available as a specialist option, plus the half-moon H grind for soft turf. The Vokey answers with the K and D grinds, so it can be forgiving too, but the Ping makes forgiveness easier to find.
Finish and looks
This one comes down to taste. The Ping Midnight is dark and anti-glare, and it looks compact at address. The Vokey Nickel Steel is a softer, mid-glare hue that sits between chrome and black. If you hate glare in bright sunshine, the Midnight is the safer pick.
Durability and technology
Titleist makes a clear durability claim, saying the heat-treated face doubles groove life without losing feel. Ping focuses on groove geometry and a textured face for consistent spin. If your wedges take a beating, the Vokey’s durability story is attractive.
| Criteria | Ping S259 Midnight | Titleist Vokey SM11 Nickel | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Feel | Grabby, consistent | Soft, flight-controlled | Vokey |
| Forgiveness | W and H grinds, wide soles | K and D grinds, wide soles | Ping |
| Grind choice | S, T, W, E, H, B | F, M, S, D, K, T | Draw |
| Looks | Dark anti-glare Midnight | Soft Nickel Steel hue | Draw |
| Durability tech | Face blast and milled grooves | Heat-treated face | Vokey |
| Price | £179 | £179 | Draw |
Performance ratings
| Rating | Ping S259 Midnight | Titleist Vokey SM11 Nickel |
|---|---|---|
| Spin and control | ★★★★★ | ★★★★★ |
| Feel | ★★★★☆ | ★★★★★ |
| Forgiveness | ★★★★★ | ★★★★☆ |
| Grind variety | ★★★★★ | ★★★★★ |
| Looks and finish | ★★★★★ | ★★★★☆ |
Ratings are our editorial view based on the manufacturers’ specifications and our team’s experience. They are not customer review scores.
Decision guide
Still undecided? Work through these priorities in order. Stop at the first one that describes you.
Priority 1: Do you want maximum forgiveness and flexibility?
- YES → Choose the Ping S259 Midnight and pick the W or H grind for steeper swings or softer turf.
- NO → Skip to Priority 2
Priority 2: Do you want a lower, controlled flight and classic Vokey feel?
- YES → Choose the Titleist Vokey SM11 Nickel Steel and pick the grind that suits your swing.
- NO → Skip to Priority 3
Priority 3: Is glare or finish your deciding factor?
- YES → Choose the Ping Midnight for dark, anti-glare looks, or the Vokey Nickel Steel for a softer, mid-glare hue.
- NO → Either wedge will serve you well, so ask our team for a fitting recommendation.
Player profiles
The Improving Mid Handicapper
Profile: Plays regularly, hits a mix of full and partial wedges and wants forgiveness on mishits.
Recommendation: Ping S259 Midnight, ideally in the W or S grind.
Why: Wide sole options and consistent spin make it easier to get the ball close.
The Feel-Driven Better Player
Profile: Hits lots of partial shots, opens the face and shapes wedges around the green.
Recommendation: Titleist Vokey SM11 Nickel Steel, in the M, S or T grind.
Why: The forward CG and Vokey Spin System reward control and shot-making.
The Sunny-Course Regular
Profile: Plays firm summer turf or bright conditions and hates glare at address.
Recommendation: Ping S259 Midnight, in the B or T grind for firm turf.
Why: The anti-glare finish keeps your focus on the ball, and low-bounce grinds suit firm lies.
Our verdict
There is no bad choice here. Both wedges cost £179, both have six grinds, and both are built for golfers who care about their short game. The Ping S259 Midnight is our pick for most golfers because it combines forgiveness, grind variety and an anti-glare finish. The Titleist Vokey SM11 Nickel Steel is the one to buy if feel and flight control come first.
Choose the Ping S259 Midnight if you want forgiveness, a dark anti-glare finish, and a wide loft range for easy gapping. Choose the Titleist Vokey SM11 Nickel Steel if you want a lower, controlled flight, enjoy opening the face and like the idea of longer groove life.
| Wedge | Our rating | Price | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ping S259 Midnight | ★★★★★ | £179 | Shop → |
| Titleist Vokey SM11 Nickel | ★★★★☆ | £179 | Shop → |
Need expert advice? Not sure which loft or grind fits your swing and your home course? Our PGA professional team is happy to help. Call us free on 0800 3681097 or email sales@thegolfshoponline.co.uk
FAQs
Which grind should I choose on the Ping S259 Midnight?
It depends on your attack angle and turf.
The W grind suits steeper swings and gives the most forgiveness, while the H grind suits soft conditions. The B grind is low bounce for firm turf and shallow swings. The S grind fits the broadest range of techniques. If you are unsure, our PGA team can recommend a grind for your swing.
Is the Titleist Vokey SM11 too difficult for a mid handicapper?
No, not if you choose the right grind.
The SM11 is a tour-proven wedge, but the K grind has a wide, full sole with extra camber, and the D grind adds high bounce for steeper swings. Both are friendlier than many golfers expect. Our team can talk you through which suits your swing and your typical lies.
What does the Midnight finish do on the Ping S259?
It reduces glare at address.
The dark coating is anti-glare and gives a visually compact look, which helps in bright sunshine. It is also a sharp-looking alternative to the Hydropearl 2.0 Chrome finish. As with any coated finish, expect some wear marks with heavy use, so wipe the face clean after each round.
What is the Vokey Spin System?
A process for more predictable greenside spin.
It is the new engineering process behind the SM11, designed to make spin more consistent so you can trust the shot you plan. Titleist pairs it with spin-milled grooves, which are inspected, and a heat-treated face designed to double groove life while keeping its feel.
Can I get these wedges custom fitted?
Yes, our team can advise on lofts and grinds.
Full custom fit options are available on the Vokey SM11, and the Ping S259 comes in a wide range of lofts and grinds. Our PGA professional team can help you choose the right combination. Call us free on 0800 3681097 or email us before you order.
What if I buy the wrong loft or grind?
You are covered by our 60-Day Returns Policy.
If you are unhappy with any product, you may return it unused, unopened and in its original packaging within 60 days for a full refund. Combined with free UK standard delivery over £30, you can order with confidence and ask our team for help first.
Ready to sharpen your short game?
Free UK standard delivery over £30 and our 60-Day Returns Policy on both wedges.
Why Purchase Your Golf Wedge from The Golf Shop Online?
Award-Winning Service Since 2002
Average Rating: 4.9 out of 5.0
29,000+ Total Reviews
8,000+ on Reviews.co.uk · 6,000+ on Trustpilot · 15,000+ on Google
Led by PGA professional Mark Crossfield, with over 330 million YouTube views
60-Day Returns
If you are unhappy with any product, you may return it unused, unopened and in its original packaging within 60 days for a full refund.
Free UK Standard Delivery
Every order over £30 comes with free standard UK delivery.
Authorised Retailer
We supply genuine products from all the major brands, with full manufacturer warranties.
Expert PGA Guidance
Our team of PGA professionals is on hand to help with fit, sizing and choosing the right kit.
Lowest Price Promise
Find it cheaper elsewhere, and we’ll match it, so you can buy with confidence.
Real Golfers, Real Reviews
Thousands of independent reviews from golfers who have shopped with us.
Complete Your Setup: Short Game Essentials
- Golf balls – pair your wedges with a ball that gives the greenside spin and feel you want.
- Golf putters – finish the job on the green with a putter that suits your stroke.
- Golf irons – match your wedge gapping to your iron set for smooth distance steps.
- Golf bags – find a bag with space for a four-wedge set and all your essentials.
- Golf shoes – stay stable on awkward lies around the green.
- Golf clothing – dress for the weather so nothing gets in the way of your short game.
If you are curious how grooves and equipment are regulated, check The R&A for the latest rules and equipment guidance. For more wedge reading, see our Titleist SM11 Black Vapor guide, our Callaway Opus vs Cleveland CBZ comparison and the best golf lob wedges.
Disclaimer: Prices, specifications, and availability are accurate as of publication but may change. All Ping and Titleist products featured are genuine products from an authorised retailer. Product performance may vary based on individual use and care. 60-Day Returns Policy: If you are unhappy with any product, you may return it — unused, unopened, and in its original packaging — within 60 days for a full refund. Free UK Standard Delivery: Every order over £30 from The Golf Shop Online comes with free standard UK delivery.
For the most current pricing, availability, and product specifications, please visit our website or contact our team on 0800 3681097. The Golf Shop Online has served golfers since 2002, with award-winning customer service backed by 29,000+ verified reviews across Reviews.co.uk, Trustpilot, and Google.
Related Posts
-
Ping S259 Vs Vokey SM11 – Which £179 Wedge Wins?Ping S259 vs Vokey SM11 Nickel: Which £179 Wedge...
- October 14, 2026
-
Best Zero Torque Putters 2026: Top 5 Ranked by PGA Pros
Best Zero Torque Putters 2026: Top 5 Ranked by...
- October 13, 2026
-
Best Golf Quarter Zip Sweaters 2026: Our Top 5 Picks
Top 5 Men’s Quarter-Zip Golf Pullovers for 2026 Quick...
- October 13, 2026
-
Understanding the Ping Colour Chart & Dot System
Ping Colour Chart – can you understand it?...
- September 20, 2026
-
Ping Grip Sizes – How to Choose The Correct Golf Grip
If you have read our blog on choosing the...
- September 16, 2026
-
Can I custom fit Ping Golf Clubs online?
A frequent question our golf professionals get while speaking...
- November 9, 2020
![X [Twitter]](https://www.thegolfshoponline.co.uk/assets/themes/gso2022/images/footer/icon-x.png){kind=icon}
